The Stainless Steel Rat (stainsteelrat) wrote,
The Stainless Steel Rat

Second Thoughts On HD or The HD Backlash

I like to consider myself a geek that considers. As opposed to a geek that gets a hard on from the mere mention of some technical wizardry* (I did once contemplate switching my LJ username to theantigeek).

*There's a fantastic Lee Evans skit that exemplifies this, from one of his stand up shows, but I'll be damned if I can find it.

That is when some new bit of gadge comes out I like to think that I mostly consider it with a weather eye.

And case in point: when the tech media started their mutual masturbation about High Definition (HD), I did wonder whether it was going to be all that was being made of it.

I was living in Brazil - a cutting edge tech backwater courtesy of low salaries and insane import taxes - at the time the "HD Revolution" kicked off, so could really just look on as HD TVs took their first tentative steps into the "First World" market.

But 2-3 years on, when I was back in the UK, it was mere months before I had an HD TV, then Sky HD, and then a Blu-Ray player.

*But* 2 years further on, in present day June 2010, and I only have a handful of Blu-Ray discs, and have cancelled Sky HD.

Why? Because I just don't find HD that big a deal. What concerned me around the time of the HD revolution was that the discussion was more about the technical aspects of it, rather than what the technology would leverage. And as with any technology it's that cost trade off - does the technology actually leverage something of value? Therein lies the endless debate of course about whether fine detail in a film/programme actually adds to it.

For me it doesn't, at least it's not something I would pay over the odds for. Given the choice I will still record something on BBC or C4 HD (free-to-air on Sky). Given the choice I will still buy a Blu-Ray rather than a DVD, if the price isn't markedly different.

And inevitably HD will creep into everyone's lives as the free-to-air channels move over, and DVD fades away (with a big "perhaps" attached to that, as although Blu-Ray has done OK, it is just OK).

(Also with the boom in digital downloads is there any real need for yet-another-physical format i.e. Blu-Ray? Just, I suspect)

And the next leap to 3D TV? I have serious misgivings about that.

  • 2020 Faves

    (I wrote the bulk of this a few days ago, so might as well post it on the usual day) As is the annual tradition, my favourite films, TV, music, and…

  • (no subject)

    Thursday. Back to Joe Wicks after a 3 day break. Nothing of consequence at work. I got a frantic call from Mum late evening to say she wanted to…

  • Faves of 2019

    As is the annual tradition, my favourite films, TV, music, and games from 2019. Films. 2019 was the #YearOfFilm where I tried, and succeeded, to…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded